Why Almost Half of Brands Cannot Measure Creative Impact, and What It Costs

Share this post

Marketing has never measured more and never understood less about the thing that actually moves the needle. New research from Marketing Week, Kantar and Google puts a hard number on it. 47.9% of brands have no mechanism to measure the impact of their creative work. Not a weak mechanism. None at all.

That is the most important branding statistic published this year, and it explains why so many brand teams feel permanently busy and quietly stuck. In this post I unpack what the number really means, why the gap exists, what it costs in profit rather than pride, and what the evidence says about closing it.

If you set budgets, sign off design work, or defend brand investment to a finance director, this is the data you want in your back pocket before your next planning meeting.

The number: half the market is flying blind on its most valuable asset

The 2026 edition of The Language of Effectiveness, produced by Marketing Week in partnership with Kantar and Google, surveyed more than 600 brand-side marketers. Among its headline findings, 47.9% of brands lack the mechanism to quantify creative impact, and 71.7% admit that ease of measurement dictates where their budget goes.

Read those two figures together, because separately they are merely awkward. Together they describe a structural bias. If almost half of all brands cannot measure creative quality, and seven in ten allocate spend towards whatever is easiest to measure, then money flows away from the work that shapes long-term brand value and towards the work that produces a tidy dashboard by Friday.

This is not new, but the scale of it is newly documented. An earlier wave of the same research, reported by Google’s Think with Google team, found that eight in ten marketers see creative quality as a key driver of effectiveness while only 46.2% had any analysis in place to measure it. Belief was close to universal. Evidence was close to a coin flip.

What makes this a branding problem rather than an advertising problem is the breadth of what counts as creative. Creative is not only a thirty second film. It is the identity system, the logo, the typography, the colour palette, the pack architecture, the tone of voice, the website, the retail environment. Every one of those assets either earns attention and memory or quietly loses it. If you cannot measure creative quality, you cannot tell which of your brand assets are working, which are decorative, and which are actively costing you money.

Why the gap exists, and why it is not laziness

It would be easy to read 47.9% as evidence that marketers are careless. The research suggests something more mundane and more fixable. Simon Atherley, head of marketing effectiveness at Kantar UK, describes the causes as largely structural, citing a lack of time and budget “especially as the creative process becomes more compressed,” with teams under pressure to launch and iterate so quickly that creative analysis becomes “a nice-to-have rather than a core part of the process.” The same Google, Kantar and Marketing Week analysis found that fewer than a quarter of marketers use any single tech-enabled tool for creative measurement.

Meanwhile the production side has accelerated dramatically. The same research shows 57% of marketers using AI for creative production and 45% using it to produce variants of campaign assets. The 2026 wave shows AI moving further upstream, into strategic market research for 51.1% of teams and creative testing for 44.2%. So output volume is rising fast while evaluation capability lags. More assets, less understanding of which ones deserve to exist.

In my work as a brand identity designer London businesses come to when their brand has drifted, I see the consequence of this constantly. A client arrives with four years of assets, three iterations of their logo in active circulation, two versions of their colour palette, and no idea which combination performs. They have analytics on everything except the thing customers actually see first. The cause is rarely apathy. It is that nobody ever built the habit, and the tooling felt like someone else’s job.

There is a second, quieter reason. Measuring creative invites judgement on work that people are emotionally invested in. It is more comfortable to report a click-through rate than to learn that the rebrand everybody loved internally is less distinctive than the thing it replaced. Comfort is expensive.

The cost of not knowing: more than four times the profit

Here is where the statistic stops being an interesting industry curiosity and starts being a commercial argument. Kantar, working with WARC, matched around 450 ads from its Link database of more than 250,000 global ads against return on marketing investment figures drawn from WARC’s ROI database of over 1,100 award entries and case studies. The conclusion was blunt. The most creative and effective work generates more than four times as much profit.

That multiple is the real meaning of 47.9%. Nearly half of brands cannot see the variable with the largest known effect on profitability. Imagine a finance team that could not measure gross margin. Nobody would tolerate it for a quarter.

The detail inside that Kantar and WARC analysis matters even more for brand owners. Short-term measures of sales likelihood did correlate with profit, but the stronger relationship came from Demand Power Contribution, a measure built on an ad’s ability to drive meaningfulness, difference and salience for the brand. In other words, the long-term brand-building properties of creative work predicted profit better than its immediate persuasion. Kantar’s own conclusion is that brand-building components belong in every piece of advertising regardless of objective.

This is the part that should reframe how design is budgeted. Distinctiveness is not a taste preference. It is a profit variable. When I work as a logo designer London founders hire to sharpen a mark that has stopped standing out, the conversation is usually framed as a refresh. The commercial framing is better. A logo that is instantly attributable to you, across every format from a shopfront to a 32 pixel app icon, is a permanent multiplier on every pound of media you will ever spend. Weak logo design is not a small aesthetic problem. It is a tax applied to your entire marketing budget, forever, and it compounds.

The boardroom disconnect that keeps the gap open

The 2026 research surfaces a third figure that explains why the first two persist. 71.1% of marketing teams define success differently from their CEO and CFO. That is not a communication problem. It is a currency problem. Two departments are keeping score in different units and then arguing about who is winning.

When marketing reports in impressions, engagement rate and cost per click, while the board thinks in revenue, margin and pricing power, the safest survival strategy for a marketing leader is to over-index on whatever is easiest to evidence. Hence the 71.7% who let ease of measurement dictate allocation. It is rational behaviour inside an irrational system.

The interesting counterpoint in the data is that better measurement does not shrink budgets, it grows them. In the earlier wave of the research, 51% of marketers said their budgets had risen after focusing on effectiveness measurement. Proving impact is not a compliance exercise. It is a funding strategy.

This is why I push clients towards brand positioning and strategy work before any visual execution begins. Not because strategy decks are inherently valuable, but because positioning is what gives you something falsifiable to measure. If your position states that you are the most trusted specialist in a defined category, for a defined audience, with defined reasons to believe, then you can test whether the identity, packaging, advertising and media campaigns and website are actually building that association. Without it, creative measurement has no target, and every result is arguable. Conversion rate optimisation can tell you which button colour wins. Only positioning can tell you whether you are winning the right customers at the right price.

What the market is rewarding instead: meaning, difference and pricing power

If you want to see what happens when brands do get this right, look at where value is accumulating. Kantar’s BrandZ Most Valuable Global Brands 2026 ranking put the combined value of the top 100 at a record 13.1 trillion dollars, up 22% year on year, with Google reclaiming first place at 1.5 trillion dollars and Claude debuting at number 27 with a brand value of 96.6 billion dollars.

Those numbers are dazzling and mostly irrelevant to a mid-market business. This one is not. Analysis of the same dataset, reported by Marketing Week, found that brands which improved their meaning and relevance with consumers grew brand value by an average of 129% since 2019, compared with 80% growth for brands that lost meaning over the same period. The research also found that meaning now accounts for 46% of brand pricing power in apparel and personal care.

Read that as a margin statistic, because that is what it is. Nearly half of your ability to charge more in those categories comes from whether people feel your brand is for them and meets their needs. That perception is built almost entirely through creative expression, distinctiveness and consistency. It is the output of design decisions, not discount decisions.

The same analysis showed how visibility is shifting. In UK skincare, La Roche-Posay and CeraVe achieved the highest share of large language model responses, at 11.29% and 10.94% respectively, built through clear association with specific consumer needs and a genuine presence in online culture. Machines now recommend brands based on how clearly and how often those brands are described in relation to a need. Vagueness has a new cost.

This has a very practical consequence for physical products. As a packaging designer London brands work with when they are fighting for shelf attention, I would argue packaging is now the most measurable creative asset most businesses own. It sits at the point of purchase, it can be tested in controlled conditions, it affects perceived quality and therefore price tolerance, and it appears in nearly every user-generated image and piece of social media content about your product. If you are going to start measuring creative anywhere, start where the cash register is.

What measurable creative discipline actually looks like

The evidence points to a fairly unglamorous set of habits rather than a platform purchase. Based on what the research shows and what I see working with clients, the priorities look like this:

  • Test before you produce, not after you launch. Pre-testing storyboards, identity routes and pack designs moves the decision to the point where changing your mind is cheap. Both the Google and Kantar analyses put predictive pre-testing first for exactly this reason.
  • Measure distinctiveness, not likeability. Ask whether people can attribute the asset to you without seeing your name. Attribution is the metric that links design to memory, and memory to future demand.
  • Track long-term brand measures alongside short-term response. The Kantar and WARC work found meaningfulness, difference and salience predicted profit more strongly than immediate persuasion. If you only report response, you will systematically defund the thing that earns you the most.
  • Write the rules down and enforce them. Consistency is the cheapest source of creative effectiveness available, and it is the one most often squandered. Clear brand guidelines are what stop a well-built identity fragmenting across six teams and four agencies inside two years.
  • Close the loop. Feed what you learn back into the next brief. A testing insight that never reaches the designer is a cost, not an asset.
  • Use one shared scorecard with finance. If 71.1% of teams define success differently from their CEO, the fix is a single agreed definition, agreed before the campaign, not after.

None of this requires a research budget the size of a media plan. It requires treating creative as an input variable with a measurable effect, which is exactly what the profit data says it is. As a graphic designer London clients bring in across identity, print design and digital work, I have never once regretted testing early, and I have often regretted not doing it. The projects that go wrong are almost always the ones where nobody agreed in advance what good would look like.

The takeaway: measure the asset that multiplies everything else

47.9% of brands cannot measure creative impact. 71.7% let ease of measurement decide where money goes. 71.1% define success differently from their own board. And the best creative work generates more than four times the profit of the rest, while brands that grew their meaning grew value by 129% against 80% for those that did not.

Put those figures in a line and the conclusion is uncomfortable but simple. The industry has built exceptional measurement around the delivery of marketing and almost none around the substance of it. That is why so many brands can describe their funnel in detail and cannot explain why customers choose them.

The opportunity here is genuinely asymmetric. You do not need to out-spend anyone. You need to be in the half of the market that knows which of its creative assets are working, and why. Start with the assets that carry the most weight, which for most businesses means the logo, the identity system, the packaging and the website. Define what distinctiveness means for your category. Test before you commit. Report creative quality next to revenue, in the same language your CFO already uses.

Do that and you stop arguing about taste and start arguing about profit. On current evidence, that is an argument brand and design work wins comfortably.

Lee Mason

I'm a Brand Strategist, Creative Director and Freelance Graphic Designer, London.

Share this post

Related Posts

If your identity isn't distinctive, you're very likely paying for that every month. You pay in assets that get rebuilt, campaigns that have to explain who you are, recognition that gets lost to competitors, and refreshes that reset the clock.
The rules of brand discovery have changed dramatically. Consumers are now turning to AI tools for recommendations and advice, leaving many brands invisible in this new landscape. This post offers a practical framework for auditing your brand’s visibility in AI-driven discovery channels.
UK marketing budgets have surged to a two-year high, with a remarkable +14.3% increase in Q3 2026. In this post, we’ll explore how to effectively allocate this budget uplift, avoid common pitfalls, and leverage your brand identity to maximize impact. Discover how to turn this opportunity into a competitive advantage for your brand.